Diplomacia e Relações Internacionais
Um professor de Harvard, a convite da revista Foreign Policy, fez a sua lista dos dez melhores. Tudo deve ser visto da perspectiva americana, claro. Se fossemos pedir a um acadêmico europeu (francês, alemão, ou inglês), a lista provavelmente seria outra, e recolheria apenas dois ou três desta lista.
Vale pelo que vale, trata-se de um começo...
Relembre-se que a lista é de dois anos atrás...
Paulo Roberto de Almeida
My "top ten" books every student of International Relations should read
Posted By Stephen M. Walt
Foreign Policy, Thursday, April 9, 2009
Last week Tom Ricks offered us his "Top Ten list" of books any student of military history should read. The FP staff asked me to follow suit with some of my favorites from the world of international politics and foreign policy. What follows aren't necessarily the books I'd put on a graduate syllabus; instead, here are ten books that either had a big influence on my thinking, were a pleasure to read, or are of enduring value for someone trying to make sense of contemporary world politics. But I've just scratched the surface here, so I invite readers to contribute their own suggestions.
1) Kenneth Waltz, Man, the State, and War
An all-time classic, which I first read as a college sophomore. Not only did M, S & W provide an enduring typology of different theories of war (i.e., locating them either in the nature of man, the characteristics of states, or the anarchic international system), but Waltz offers incisive critiques of these three "images" (aka "levels of analysis.") Finding out that this book began life as Waltz's doctoral dissertation was a humbling moment in my own graduate career.
2) Jared Diamond, Guns, Germs, and Steel
Combines biology and macro-history in a compelling fashion, explaining why small differences in climate, population, agronomy, and the like turned out to have far-reaching effects on the evolution of human societies and the long-term balance of power. An exhilarating read.
3) Thomas Schelling, Arms and Influence
He's a Nobel Prize winner now, so one expects a lot of smart ideas. Some of Schelling's ideas do not seem to have worked well in practice (cf. Robert Pape's Bombing to Win and Wallace Thies's When Governments Collide) but more than anyone else, Schelling taught us all to think about military affairs in a genuinely strategic fashion. (The essays found in Schelling's Strategy of Conflict are more technical but equally insightful). And if only more scholars wrote as well.
4) James Scott, Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed
This isn't really a book about international relations, but it's a fascinating exploration of the origins of great human follies (like Prussian "scientific forestry" or Stalinist collectivized agriculture). Scott pins the blame for these grotesque man-made disasters on centralized political authority (i.e., the absence of dissent) and "totalistic" ideologies that sought to impose uniformity and order in the name of some dubious pseudo-scientific blueprint. And it's a book that aspiring "nation-builders" and liberal interventionists should read as an antidote to their own ambitions. Reading Scott's work (to include his Weapons of the Weak and Domination and the Arts of Resistance) provided the intellectual launching pad for my book Taming American Power).
5) David Halberstam, The Best and the Brightest
Stayed up all night reading this compelling account of a great national tragedy, and learned not to assume that the people in charge knew what they were doing. Still relevant today, no?
6) Robert Jervis, Perception and Misperception in International Politics
I read this while tending bar at the Stanford Faculty Club in 1977 (the Stanford faculty weren't big drinkers so I had a lot of free time). Arguably still the best single guide to the ways that psychology can inform our understanding of world politics. Among other things, it convinced that I would never know as much history as Jervis does. I was right.
7) John J. Mearsheimer, The Tragedy of Great Power Politics
Why do bad things happen to good peoples? Why do "good states" do lots of bad things? Mearsheimer tells you. Clearly written, controversial, and depressingly persuasive.
8) Ernst Gellner, Nations and Nationalism
The state is the dominant political form in the world today, and nationalism remains a powerful political force. This book will help you understand where it came from and why it endures.
9) Henry A. Kissinger, White House Years & Years of Upheaval
Memoirs should always be read with a skeptical eye, and Kissinger's are no exception. But if you want some idea of what it is like to run a great power's foreign policy, this is a powerfully argued and often revealing account. And Kissinger's portraits of his colleagues and counterparts are often candid and full of insights. Just don't take it at face value.
10) Karl Polanyi, The Great Transformation
Where did the modern world come from, and what are the political, economic, and social changes that it wrought? Polanyi doesn't answer every question, but he's a good place to start.
So that's ten, but I can't resist tossing in a few others in passing: Geoffrey Blainey The Causes of War; Douglas North, Structure and Change in Economic History; Valerie Hudson and Andrea den Boer, Bare Branches: The Security Implications of Asia’s Surplus Male Population; Robert Gilpin, The Political Economy of International Relations; Steve Coll, Ghost Wars; T.C.W. Blanning, The Origins of the French Revolutionary Wars; R. R. Palmer, The Age of the Democratic Revolution; Avi Shlaim, The Iron Wall: Israel and the Arab World; Stephen Van Evera, Causes of War; Samuel Huntington, Political Order in Changing Societies; Tony Smith, The Problem of Imperlalism; and Philip Knightley's The First Casualty: The War Correspondent as Hero, Propagandist, and Myth-Maker. And as I said, this just scratches the surface.
So what did I miss? Keep the bar high.
(And for those of you who don't have time to read books, I'll start working on a "top ten" list of articles).
- China-eua: Iii Guerra Mundial? (imperios Sao Paranoicos Por Natureza) - New Book From Harvard
A century ago, Europe's diplomats mismanaged the crisis triggered by the murder of Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria, and the continent soon plunged into World War I, which killed millions, toppled dynasties, and destroyed empires. Almost as soon...
- Vou Dar Um Pulinho Em Washington E Ja Volto... (a Book, Of Course...)
Se alguém tiver uma passagem sobrando, ou milhas em excesso, favor avisar. Bem que gostaria de assistir a esse lançamento. O livro vai demorar um pouco para entrar no Abebooks (em todo caso, cabe conferir...). [Já conferi: abaixo...] Hudson Institute...
- Fukuyama E O Nascimento Da Politica - City Journal
The Dawn of Politics ADAM KIRSCH City Journal, Spring 2011, vol. 21. n. 2 Francis Fukuyama goes back to the beginning. It’s possible that Francis Fukuyama does not take unmixed pleasure in his fame as the author of The End of History and the Last Man....
- Os Dez Piores Livros De Relacoes Internacionais (sempre Vistos Dos Eua...)
Depois dos dez melhores, agora os dez piores, por um outro scholar. Até abril de 2009; depois disso, outros piores foram publicados, como provavelmente as memórias de George Bush e de seu inefável Secretário "da guerra" (ele merece o título Donald...
- Debate Academico Na Unb: Ikenberry, Bagley On Us And Emerging Countries
Em parceira com a Embaixada dos Estados Unidos, o iRel promoveu hoje, quinta-feira, dia 5/5, às 9:30h, na sala FA A1-04, uma mesa redonda com os professores JOHN G. IKENBERRY (Princeton), que falou sobre "Os BRICS e a Nova Ordem Global: A Visão dos...
Diplomacia e Relações Internacionais
Os Dez Melhores Livros de Relacoes Internacionais (vistos dos EUA, claro...)
Um professor de Harvard, a convite da revista Foreign Policy, fez a sua lista dos dez melhores. Tudo deve ser visto da perspectiva americana, claro. Se fossemos pedir a um acadêmico europeu (francês, alemão, ou inglês), a lista provavelmente seria outra, e recolheria apenas dois ou três desta lista.
Vale pelo que vale, trata-se de um começo...
Relembre-se que a lista é de dois anos atrás...
Paulo Roberto de Almeida
My "top ten" books every student of International Relations should read
Posted By Stephen M. Walt
Foreign Policy, Thursday, April 9, 2009
Last week Tom Ricks offered us his "Top Ten list" of books any student of military history should read. The FP staff asked me to follow suit with some of my favorites from the world of international politics and foreign policy. What follows aren't necessarily the books I'd put on a graduate syllabus; instead, here are ten books that either had a big influence on my thinking, were a pleasure to read, or are of enduring value for someone trying to make sense of contemporary world politics. But I've just scratched the surface here, so I invite readers to contribute their own suggestions.
1) Kenneth Waltz, Man, the State, and War
An all-time classic, which I first read as a college sophomore. Not only did M, S & W provide an enduring typology of different theories of war (i.e., locating them either in the nature of man, the characteristics of states, or the anarchic international system), but Waltz offers incisive critiques of these three "images" (aka "levels of analysis.") Finding out that this book began life as Waltz's doctoral dissertation was a humbling moment in my own graduate career.
2) Jared Diamond, Guns, Germs, and Steel
Combines biology and macro-history in a compelling fashion, explaining why small differences in climate, population, agronomy, and the like turned out to have far-reaching effects on the evolution of human societies and the long-term balance of power. An exhilarating read.
3) Thomas Schelling, Arms and Influence
He's a Nobel Prize winner now, so one expects a lot of smart ideas. Some of Schelling's ideas do not seem to have worked well in practice (cf. Robert Pape's Bombing to Win and Wallace Thies's When Governments Collide) but more than anyone else, Schelling taught us all to think about military affairs in a genuinely strategic fashion. (The essays found in Schelling's Strategy of Conflict are more technical but equally insightful). And if only more scholars wrote as well.
4) James Scott, Seeing Like a State: How Certain Schemes to Improve the Human Condition Have Failed
This isn't really a book about international relations, but it's a fascinating exploration of the origins of great human follies (like Prussian "scientific forestry" or Stalinist collectivized agriculture). Scott pins the blame for these grotesque man-made disasters on centralized political authority (i.e., the absence of dissent) and "totalistic" ideologies that sought to impose uniformity and order in the name of some dubious pseudo-scientific blueprint. And it's a book that aspiring "nation-builders" and liberal interventionists should read as an antidote to their own ambitions. Reading Scott's work (to include his Weapons of the Weak and Domination and the Arts of Resistance) provided the intellectual launching pad for my book Taming American Power).
5) David Halberstam, The Best and the Brightest
Stayed up all night reading this compelling account of a great national tragedy, and learned not to assume that the people in charge knew what they were doing. Still relevant today, no?
6) Robert Jervis, Perception and Misperception in International Politics
I read this while tending bar at the Stanford Faculty Club in 1977 (the Stanford faculty weren't big drinkers so I had a lot of free time). Arguably still the best single guide to the ways that psychology can inform our understanding of world politics. Among other things, it convinced that I would never know as much history as Jervis does. I was right.
7) John J. Mearsheimer, The Tragedy of Great Power Politics
Why do bad things happen to good peoples? Why do "good states" do lots of bad things? Mearsheimer tells you. Clearly written, controversial, and depressingly persuasive.
8) Ernst Gellner, Nations and Nationalism
The state is the dominant political form in the world today, and nationalism remains a powerful political force. This book will help you understand where it came from and why it endures.
9) Henry A. Kissinger, White House Years & Years of Upheaval
Memoirs should always be read with a skeptical eye, and Kissinger's are no exception. But if you want some idea of what it is like to run a great power's foreign policy, this is a powerfully argued and often revealing account. And Kissinger's portraits of his colleagues and counterparts are often candid and full of insights. Just don't take it at face value.
10) Karl Polanyi, The Great Transformation
Where did the modern world come from, and what are the political, economic, and social changes that it wrought? Polanyi doesn't answer every question, but he's a good place to start.
So that's ten, but I can't resist tossing in a few others in passing: Geoffrey Blainey The Causes of War; Douglas North, Structure and Change in Economic History; Valerie Hudson and Andrea den Boer, Bare Branches: The Security Implications of Asia’s Surplus Male Population; Robert Gilpin, The Political Economy of International Relations; Steve Coll, Ghost Wars; T.C.W. Blanning, The Origins of the French Revolutionary Wars; R. R. Palmer, The Age of the Democratic Revolution; Avi Shlaim, The Iron Wall: Israel and the Arab World; Stephen Van Evera, Causes of War; Samuel Huntington, Political Order in Changing Societies; Tony Smith, The Problem of Imperlalism; and Philip Knightley's The First Casualty: The War Correspondent as Hero, Propagandist, and Myth-Maker. And as I said, this just scratches the surface.
So what did I miss? Keep the bar high.
(And for those of you who don't have time to read books, I'll start working on a "top ten" list of articles).
loading...
- China-eua: Iii Guerra Mundial? (imperios Sao Paranoicos Por Natureza) - New Book From Harvard
A century ago, Europe's diplomats mismanaged the crisis triggered by the murder of Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria, and the continent soon plunged into World War I, which killed millions, toppled dynasties, and destroyed empires. Almost as soon...
- Vou Dar Um Pulinho Em Washington E Ja Volto... (a Book, Of Course...)
Se alguém tiver uma passagem sobrando, ou milhas em excesso, favor avisar. Bem que gostaria de assistir a esse lançamento. O livro vai demorar um pouco para entrar no Abebooks (em todo caso, cabe conferir...). [Já conferi: abaixo...] Hudson Institute...
- Fukuyama E O Nascimento Da Politica - City Journal
The Dawn of Politics ADAM KIRSCH City Journal, Spring 2011, vol. 21. n. 2 Francis Fukuyama goes back to the beginning. It’s possible that Francis Fukuyama does not take unmixed pleasure in his fame as the author of The End of History and the Last Man....
- Os Dez Piores Livros De Relacoes Internacionais (sempre Vistos Dos Eua...)
Depois dos dez melhores, agora os dez piores, por um outro scholar. Até abril de 2009; depois disso, outros piores foram publicados, como provavelmente as memórias de George Bush e de seu inefável Secretário "da guerra" (ele merece o título Donald...
- Debate Academico Na Unb: Ikenberry, Bagley On Us And Emerging Countries
Em parceira com a Embaixada dos Estados Unidos, o iRel promoveu hoje, quinta-feira, dia 5/5, às 9:30h, na sala FA A1-04, uma mesa redonda com os professores JOHN G. IKENBERRY (Princeton), que falou sobre "Os BRICS e a Nova Ordem Global: A Visão dos...