Diplomacia e Relações Internacionais
O Ocidente, o resto e o mundo de ninguem - book review, Charles A. Kupchan
International Affairs, July 2013
Book review
Charles A. Kupchan:
No one’s world: the West, the rising rest and the coming global turn
New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press. 2012. 272pp.
Index. £16.99. isbn 978 0 19973 939 4. Available as e-book.
What will replace the western world order once the United States is no longer capable of exercising global leadership? Will China’s rise be ‘unpeaceful’ and prove to be disruptive, as John Mearsheimer argues, or will rising powers support today’s system that is ‘easy to join and hard to overturn’, as G. John Ikenberry predicts? Who will rule the world once the United States’ reign ends, and what will such a world look like? Is it a ‘post-American world’, a ‘Chinese world’, or simply a western world order under non-western leadership?
Rejecting such predictions, Charles Kupchan predicts that tomorrow’s world will ‘belong to no one’. Before elaborating on this claim, the author briskly moves through centuries of history to explain why the West was quickly able to develop economically and leave other, traditionally successful, regions behind, thus initiating western global dominance. While the world had historically been compartmentalized, with each region operating according to culturally particular and exclusive principles, the author argues that Europe’s rise helped create one single global system: as European powers conquered the world, ‘they also exported European conceptions of sovereignty, administration, law, diplomacy, and commerce’ (p. 65)—thus creating what we now call the ‘western world order’.
Kupchan writes that ‘remaking the world in its own image was perhaps the ultimate exercise of Western power’ (p. 66). The West’s capacity to define modernity caused generations of non-western thinkers to argue about whether there was a difference between modernization and westernization. Kupchan shows that in a few decades, at least three BRIC countries will be among the world’s five leading economies, and he predicts that there will be multiple versions of modernity. Not only do the characteristics of Brazil’s, India’s and China’s rise differ markedly from Europe’s, but their cultural DNA is different, too, he argues. This is hardly news; the author fails to explain how internal peculiarities affect countries’ strategy vis-àvis the global system. His assertion that ‘much of Latin America has been captivated by left-wing populism’ and that this represents ‘an alternative to the West’s brand of liberal democracy’ is controversial (p. 90). What exactly are the characteristics of the ‘West’s brand of liberal democracy’? Is Brazil’s democratic system fundamentally different from, say, Portugal’s?
loading...
-
Niall Ferguson: The Ascendance Of The West (selection From His Book Civilization)
Civilization Niall Ferguson From Delanceyplace, December 12, 2013 In today's selection -- from Civilization by Niall Ferguson. The year 2013 is a vantage point from which we can clearly see the ascendance of China and much of the...
-
Sean W. Burges “brazil As A Bridge Between Old And New Powers?”
New Research on Brazil’s Rise as a Global PowerBY DR. SEAN BURGES, SENIOR RESEARCH FELLOW AT THE COUNCIL ON HEMISPHERIC AFFAIRS AS WELL AS AN ASSISTANT PROFESSOR IN INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS AT THE AUSTRALIAN NATIONAL UNIVERSITY – POSTED...
-
A Singular Alienacao De Um Academico Americano E A Fantasmagoria Do Declinio Dos Eua
Alienação é um conceito hegeliano, apropriado e trabalho por Marx, e muito usado nos anos 1960, depois que Erich Fromm, Herbert Marcuse e outros popularizaram o marxismo acadêmico, uma versão light, ou gramsciana, do velho marxismo-leninismo, ou...
-
O Mito Do Declinio Americano - Walter Russell Mead
OPINIONThe Wall Street Journal, April 8, 2012, 6:37 p.m. ET Walter Russell Mead: The Myth of America's DeclineWashington now has added China, India, Brazil and Turkey to its speed-dial, along with Europe and Japan. But it will remain the chairman...
-
Debate Academico Na Unb: Ikenberry, Bagley On Us And Emerging Countries
Em parceira com a Embaixada dos Estados Unidos, o iRel promoveu hoje, quinta-feira, dia 5/5, às 9:30h, na sala FA A1-04, uma mesa redonda com os professores JOHN G. IKENBERRY (Princeton), que falou sobre "Os BRICS e a Nova Ordem Global: A Visão dos...
Diplomacia e Relações Internacionais