Diplomacia e Relações Internacionais

NSA spy work: the Decision Problem - Goerge Dyson (The Edge)

-----------------------------

THE THIRD CULTURE

-----------------------------

NSA: THE DECISION PROBLEM

by George Dyson

Edge.org, July 26, 2013

http://www.edge.org

...The ultimate goal of signals intelligence and analysis is to learn not only what is being said, and what is being done, but what is being thought. With the proliferation of search engines that directly track the links between individual human minds and the words, images, and ideas that both characterize and increasingly constitute their thoughts, this goal appears within reach at last. "But, how can the machine know what I think?" you ask. It does not need to know what you think—no more than one person ever really knows what another person thinks. A reasonable guess at what you are thinking is good enough.

Data mining, on the scale now practiced by Google and the NSA, is the realization of what Alan Turing was getting at, in 1939, when he wondered "how far it is possible to eliminate intuition, and leave only ingenuity," in postulating what he termed an "Oracle Machine." He had already convinced himself of the possibility of what we now call artificial intelligence (in his more precise terms, mechanical intelligence) and was curious as to whether intuition could be similarly reduced to a mechanical procedure—although it might (indeed should) involve non-deterministic steps. He assumed, for sake of argument, that "we do not mind how much ingenuity is required, and therefore assume it to be available in unlimited supply."

And, as if to discount disclaimers by the NSA that they are only capturing metadata, Turing, whose World War II work on the Enigma would make him one of the patron saints of the NSA, was already explicit that it is the metadata that count. If Google has taught us anything, it is that if you simply capture enough links, over time, you can establish meaning, follow ideas, and reconstruct someone's thoughts. It is only a short step from suggesting what a target may be thinking now, to suggesting what that target may be thinking next.

Does this not promise a safer world, protected not only from bad actors attempting to do dangerous things, but from bad actors developing dangerous thoughts? Yes, but at what cost? There's a problem, and it's the problem that Alan Turing was trying to answer when he first set us down this path. Turing delivered us into the digital age, as a 24-year-old graduate student, not by building a computer, but by writing a purely mathematical paper, "On Computable Numbers, with an Application to the Entscheidungsproblem," published in 1936. The Decision Problem, articulated by Göttingen's David Hilbert, concerned the abstract mathematical question of whether there could ever be any systematic mechanical procedure to determine, in a finite number of steps, whether any given string of symbols represented a provable statement or not. . . . [more: http://www.edge.org/conversation/nsa-the-decision-problem ]

GEORGE DYSON, Science Historian, is the author of TURING'S CATHEDRAL: THE ORIGINS OF THE DIGITAL UNIVERSE, and DARWIN AMONG THE MACHINES.

[ED. NOTE: George Dyson's piece was commissioned by Frank Schirrmacher, co-publisher of the national German newspaper FRANKFURTER ALLGEMEINE ZEITUNG (FAZ), where he is Editor of the Feuilleton, cultural and science pages of the paper. First published by FAZ on July 26, 2013.]

- De Volta Aos Saloes Do Iluminismo? Desta Vez Em Ambiente Virtual... - The Edge
Edge.org October 2, 2014 http://www.edge.org --------------------------------------------------- THE THIRD CULTURE --------------------------------------------------- "Despite their intense scientific depth, John Brockman runs these gatherings with the...

- Toda Crianca Agora Tem Um Smartphone? Hum... Para Decorar Nomes De Presidentes? Hummmm...
Have smartphones in every pocket made memorization obsolete?By David PogueScientific American, August 2013 When my father was growing up, his father offered him 25 cents to memorize the complete list of U.S. presidents. “Number one, George Washington....

- O Guru Da Eterna Inteligencia: Ray Kurzweill
Interview Will Google's Ray Kurzweil Live Forever? The Wall Street Journal, April 12, 2013 In 15 years, the famous inventor expects medical technology will add a year of life expectancy every year. Ray Kurzweil must encounter his share of interviewers...

- Daron Acemoglu Conversation: Institutional Development
THE WORLD THROUGH INSTITUTIONAL LENSESA Conversation with Daron Acemoglu [9.12.12] The issue is that when you look at the world from these sorts of institutional lenses, identifying problems becomes relatively easy. Solving them becomes very...

- Stephen Jay Gould On “the Bell Curve”
Stephen Jay Gould on “The Bell Curve” Abagond, Sat 10 Jul 2010 Disclaimer: I have not read “The Bell Curve” for myself. The following is based instead on Stephen Jay Gould’s take on it. As a professor of biology at Harvard he knows the science...

Diplomacia e Relações Internacionais