Diplomacia e Relações Internacionais

A imprensa ocidental se engana a respeito do Egito - Abdallah Schleifer (Al-Arabia.net)

Western Media Misunderstands Egypt

August 16, 2013

This article, by FPRI Senior Fellow Abdallah Schleifer, originally appeared on AlArabia.net on August 13, 2013. Writing from Cairo, Schleifer is Professor Emeritus of Journalism at the American University in Cairo.

I have been shocked by the shallow way the Western media has covered the political situation in Cairo since the coup against former President Mursi.

One would never know from reading The New York Times editorials and a good deal of its coverage – along with that of other leading news organizations – that the Egyptian armed forces had moved against a political movement attempting to impose an authoritarian regime on the country.

One would never know that, aside from coached demonstrators, the exultation stirring the crowd at Cairo’s Rabaa al-Adawiya protest camp was for martyrdom and not really for democracy.

One would never know, until pollsters finally released data on the subject, that the overwhelming majority of Egyptians were opposed to Muslim Brotherhood (MB) sit-ins and marches. These disrupted both the traffic and a more general recovery in tourism, investment, job creation, law and order – leading to calls for the sit-ins to end, one way or another.

One would never know, given the absence of any real political parties with grassroots support aside from the Muslim Brotherhood, that the Egyptian army – with its massive number of conscripts and status as a symbol of Egyptian independence – is the most significant popular institution in this country, along with al-Azhar, Egypt’s top Islamic institution.

One would never know any of this, because it was a military intervention which deposed Mursi – and not a bloody civil war between a couple of million MB and allied Salafi supporters, and the many, many more opposed to the drift to an Islamist dictatorship. And that – a civil war – is something media can focus on.

From much of the Western coverage, few would recall how press freedom was undermined during Mursi’s one-year rule. This was overshadowed in reports of how the army closed down MB media outlets after Mursi’s ouster. However, tomorrow that period will be surveyed, along with the present situation, in a Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) report called “On the divide: Press Freedom at Risk in Egypt”.

Uncomfortable with the Military

The skewed media coverage of Egypt is partly due to something intrinsic in journalism, which makes so many of its practitioners uncomfortable or hostile to a professional army. Some Western journalists –Americans in particular – make psychological associations between military forces and the U.S. Army’s role in Vietnam, Afghanistan and Iraq.

Many aspects of the media and military are at polar opposites. Skepticism is a necessary journalistic virtue, versus honor and respect for one’s superior officers in the military. ‘Nothing is sacred’ is a plausible perspective for journalists, in the impromptu atmosphere of the newsroom. Compare this with the sacred duty, or ritual-like ceremonies of the military: the raising and lowering of the flag, and the solemn honor guards escorting army parades.

Journalists react with great speed to an event: the need to scoop the competition is a journalistic virtue. But armies need cautious deliberation in actions that can mean death and destruction.

Military principles seem distant to the media in America and Europe, where conscription ended years ago and nearly all journalists are too young to identify with the critical role played by U.S. armed forces in defeating the Nazis during World War II.

So in coverage of Egypt, the journalists face something unknowable and incongruous to them – the military.

- Israel’s Reshuffled Strategic Deck - Ilan Berman
E-NOTESIsrael’s Reshuffled Strategic DeckIlan BermanForeign Policy Research Institute, August 2013 In 2012, amid the ongoing ferment of the so-called “Arab Spring,” officials throughout the Israeli government were expressing deep concern about their...

- Egito: Os Dilemas De El Baradei (wp)
Three reasons Mohamed ElBaradei is an odd choice to be Egypt’s new prime minister By Max Fisher The Washington Post, July 6, 2013 Mohamed ElBaradei, the 71-year-old Nobel Peace Prize winner, former head of the United Nations’ nuclear agency and Egyptian...

- "liberdade" Religiosa No Egito: Familia Condenada Por Se Converter Aocristianismo
Egyptian court sentences Christian family to 15 years for converting from Islam By Benjamin Weinthal FoxNews.com, January 16, 2013 Critics fear Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi's regime is taking the nation further toward Islamic extremism. ...

- Nacionalismo: Essa Velha Forca Reacionaria E Anti-democratica - Robert kaplan (wsj)
OPINION The Wall Street Journal, December 23, 2012 The Return of Toxic Nationalism The spread of universal values is being rolled back on many fronts, from Russia to the Middle East. By ROBERT D. KAPLAN Western elites believe that universal values are...

- Venezuela No Mercosul: E A Imprensa, De Fora?
PRESS FREEDOM GROUP: VENEZUELA MEDIA UNDER ASSAULTBY IAN JAMES ASSOCIATED PRESS, Aug 29, 10:50 AM EDT CARACAS, Venezuela (AP) -- The Committee to Protect Journalists said in a new report Wednesday that Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez's...

Diplomacia e Relações Internacionais